Signal (Series Review)

Perfection from beginning ’til end.


signalposter

Characters:

  • Lee Je Hoon as Park Hae Young
  • Kim Hye Soo as Cha Soo Hyun
  • Cho Jin Woong as Lee Jae Han
  • Jang Hyun Sung as Kim Bum Joo
  • Jung Hae Kyun as Ahn Chi Soo
  • Kim Won Hae as Kim Hye Chul
  • Lee Yoo Joon as Jung Hun Gi

Details:

  • Korean
  • 16 episodes
  • Original run: January 22 – March 12, 2016

Quick Rundown:

After being assigned to the newly formed Cold Case Squad as its profiler, Park Hae Young discovers a walkie talkie that allows him to communicate with Detective Lee Jae Han from 1986. With knowledge of events in both the past and present, they work together to solve a series of cold cases. Meanwhile, Hae Young’s team leader, Cha Soo Hyun, has been searching for the past 15 years for her missing senior…Lee Jae Han. As more cases are solved, a larger conspiracy is revealed that affects all three of their lives, past and present.

signal-18

Anna’s Take

At first, the premise of Signal appealed to me because I usually prefer TV shows and movies that have a bit more darkness and grit to them. The problem with that, however, is most dramas usually stay away from dark storylines in favor of more cutesy cheerfulness or heartwrenching melodrama. That’s probably why my favorite American/Western TV shows are the ones that have a darker, somber tone, and I turn to dramas when I want something more lighthearted and fun. Upon reading the synopsis for Signal, I thought that this might possibly be the first time my dramas and TV show preference will actually meet! Well, Signal not only met my expectations, it exceeded them beyond what I thought was possible. Never before have I watched a drama as enthralling and exciting as this one, and it proved that the perfect drama does indeed exist.

Please, please do not let the idea of a “magical walkie talkie” deter you from watching Signal. It’s not a gimmick; it only sounds like one. Never once was the walkie talkie treated like some sort of joke, but instead was seamlessly worked into the story as an integral part of it. The walkie talkie formed the basis of the plot and much of the story is filtered through it, but it never overshadowed its characters or their relationships. Trust me when I tell you that this plot (and literal) device worked to covey key moments of tension, heartbreak, desperation, and optimism. Signal is one of those rare dramas that can elicit a multitude of emotions from its viewers simply through its storytelling capability and not from cheap tricks. From fear to joy to despair, I felt them all while watching the story unfold.

signal-4

In an age and medium where all plotlines are recycled to a certain degree, Signal was able to give viewers something they’ve never seen before. I was kept guessing at every twist and turn of the story, never knowing what was going to happen next. There were so many moments when I thought to myself, “No way that’d work,” or “How are the writers going to dig themselves out of that one,” but it somehow always did. To me, that’s a sign of a great drama; one where they can paint themselves into a corner but still find an escape. I’ll admit that I was initially a little disappointed that it wasn’t about just one murder case, but I soon realized that it was for the best. The series of cold cases dealt with throughout only enhanced the big picture vision of the drama. Because of the writers’ abilities to see and plan beyond just the first couple of episodes allowed for the big conspiracy bombshell at the end to be that much more shocking.

signal-1

Much of Signal‘s success is rightfully credited to its phenomenal writing, but just as important and impactful was the inspired acting by all of its actors. There honestly were no weak links or distracting performances from anyone in the cast. While Lee Je Hoon was a bit over-expressive in the beginning in his portrayal of the jaded and stubborn Park Hae Young, he soon reined in that energy for the better. He really shone in his scenes with Kim Hye Soo because they shared excellent chemistry, but my favorite moments were actually those of him sitting alone in the car with just the walkie talkie. He has a quiet confidence about him that makes his acting and character very likeable. I’m slightly disappointed that he didn’t actually share any screentime with Cho Jin Woong, but the scenes between their characters were satisfying.

Cho Jin Woong’s Lee Jae Han character probably experienced the least amount of development out of the three, but that’s not really his fault. Because he was relegated to scenes and plotlines set exclusively in the past, the audience never got the chance to truly meet the present-day version of him. I loved the sympathetic portrayal of this righteous character, and he’s one of those heroes that you truly root for. Like Lee Je Hoon, Cho’s best scenes were opposite Kim Hye Soo, so it should come as no surprise that she’s my MVP of Signal. The contrast between the bright-eyed, innocent Cha Soo Hyun of the past to the hardened, reserved version in the present highlights how skillfully she acted this character. Besides the three leads, all of the supporting actors were also perfect in their roles and no one ever came off like a caricature.

signal-17

Signal is a drama that should be revered for its superb writing and acting, but also its intelligence. It could have easily turned the “magical walkie talkie” plotline into a silly and implausible gimmick, but instead it gave it credibility. This drama worked tirelessly to make every plotline and loophole seem as realistic as possible, never even giving you the chance to contemplate the reality of the situation. I loved that it had the foresight to plan all the mysteries and questions with a satisfying, but logical explanation. Not only is Signal the best Korean drama I’ve seen, it’s one of the best pieces of entertainment that I’ve ever watched. It’s not often that a drama as perfect as this comes along, so please watch! You won’t regret it.

signal-11

This & That:

  • An alumni of the School of Drama at the Korean National University of Arts, Lee Je Hoon had his acting breakthrough in 2011 for his critically acclaimed performances in several movies. He gained further recognition when he starred in the popular 2011 film, Architecture 101, as the love interest of kpop idol, Suzy Bae.
  • Lee and Cho Jin Woong were co-stars in the 2013 film, My Paparotti.
  • Kim Hye Soo starred in the star-studded 2012 film, The Thieves, that also featured Kim Soo Hyun and Jun Ji Hyun.
  • Signal’s director, Kim Won Suk, also directed the well-received 2014 tvN drama, Misaeng/Incomplete Life.
  • One of the cases featured in Signal is based on a true cold case crime. The rape and murder of 10 women in a 2 km radius over the course of five years (1986-1991) occurred in Hwaseong, Gyeonggi Province, South Korea.
    • The 2003 film, Memories of a Murder, and 2014 tvN drama, Gap Dong, are also based on the same crime.

signal-21

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “Signal (Series Review)

  1. xqx says:

    Thank you for reviewing this drama! Just finished watching it; and I totally agree with your sentiments! I too would rate it 10/10 on my drama list, and it is one of the best dramas I have seen (the other being Misaeng)!!

    Like

  2. Omg I frggin love Signal so much!! Everything was executed so perfectly that it set the bar way too high for other dramas, and now that it finished, I genuinely feel lost, nothing just seems to be as good as signal, even though descendant of the sun is great, it still falls far short from this masterpiece.

    The whole concept of the walkie talkie that connects the past and present has also once been used in an old tvb drama ιš”δΈ–θΏ½ε…‡, just that, instead of a walkie talkie it was one of those vintage brick phones, that connected the male lead to his deceased father in the past, both who works in the police force. This was aired in the early 2000s, and I was still a young kid when I watched it so I don’t know if it is as good as signal but I do remember that I enjoyed watching it, and it did have some thrilling twists and changes in it too.

    Like

    • Oh and also, the scriptwriter and Lee Je Hoon both said that they are up for a second season, and tbh the final episode did keep itself open for one, I don’t really want to keep my hopes up for nothing, but it would be absolutely amazing if this does happen~~

      Like

    • Seriously! I feel the exact same way about how Signal set the bar way too high for all other dramas. I was watching the Rain drama afterwards (Come Back Mister) and it just felt SO ridiculously silly and dumb in comparison. Ahhh, a sequel!!!

      Oohh, I never watched that TVB drama but it sounds interesting. Those old TVB dramas were so much better than what they do now lol.

      Like

      • Same I tried watching Come Back Mister too since the k-netz were complimenting how hilarious it was, but you’re right, it was too ridiculously silly for me to handle.
        And I knoww, if a sequel were to happen, they have to let the three leads meet already~~

        Aw I miss the old TVB dramas, everything is just so terribly done now, from HK dramas to TW dramas, *sigh*, oh the good old days haha

        Like

  3. I’ve heard so many good things about this drama. When I’m in the mood for something intense, I’ll have to check it out. Reminds me a bit of the movie Frequency (even the names are similar).

    Like

  4. d1735 says:

    Honestly, this plot has been done before but this one did well because the writers really organised the story to work for them. Related shows include To Get Unstuck In Time , TVB drama as well as the American movie , Frequency, released in year 2000

    Like

    • Yeah, I feel like I’ll be comparing whatever time traveling crime drama I watch from now on to Signal. Seriously one of the best of its kind!

      Like

Join the Drama

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s